In the ‘Share Applicants Between Recruiters’ sharing rule, it doesn’t look like the records are shared from the ‘Recruiter’ role.

Start by checking the "Owned by members of" setting 

- Setup > Security > Sharing Settings. Find the sharing rule 

- Select which records to be shared - ensure that "Owned by members of:" is explicitly set to Roles: Recruiter 

If that doesn't work, check the record ownership. Make sure the owner is assigned the recruiter role 

Last, you might need to recalculate the sharing rules. Go to the sharing rule and click the Recalculate button

Security > Sharing Settings." style="display: block;" />